Friday, December 20, 2013

Grand Finale 2013...

Classic Acme! Morris Plains, New Jersey


Location: 329 Speedwell Ave, Morris Plains, NJ



A late addition to the post… classic photos from the 90's!


No more requests please… the classic Morris Plains Acme is finally available on Acme Style! I've invited long-time contributor Rob to share his knowledge of the history of this store...

Acme’s presence in Morris Plains, NJ- a small suburb immediately outside of Morristown- began in 1953 with the opening of a store on Speedwell Avenue near its intersection with Hanover Avenue. As the building was constructed close to the street, parking was provided by a small lot on the right side of the building and a larger lot behind the building, leading to the possibility of the store having front and back entrances similar to the setup at Acme’s location in Fair Haven, NJ. In fact, it’s entirely possible the stores were very much alike considering them having opened around the same time.

The current Acme in Morris Plains debuted around 1978, having been constructed in what was likely a wooded area behind the original building and its rear parking lot. It was followed by a very brief period of investment in the long-neglected northern NJ market that brought a replacement to the Rockaway store and a new store to Lodi. All three were examples of the company’s new 33M format- a misleading name because most stores weren’t close to 33,000 square feet. Following the opening of the Rockaway and Lodi locations, Acme would wait more than two decades to bring further investment to northern NJ in the form of new stores in Milltown, Randolph and Clifton.



The new Morris Plains Acme likely debuted with a deluxe version of the 70’s Colonial décor package that was still in place in most of the company’s stores. Because of its success, Acme wasn’t hesitant to invest in the location and at some point in the mid-80’s, the store received the 80’s remodel which brought, among other things, a West Coast Video location near the entrance. It’s also possible this remodel saw the fisheye logo replaced with the red oval in the sign frames on the front and Hanover Avenue side of the building. The Rockaway store was also remodeled around the same time, and for the same reason- the two locations along with the long-standing Middlesex store were bright spots in an area where Acme once had a major presence but had started losing its stronghold. Many of the company’s locations were small and outdated when compared to competition from ShopRite and Pathmark and, instead of working to make things better, Acme opted to further neglect them.

The early 90’s brought another upgrade to the Morris Plains Acme in the form of the checkerboard arch décor package. This remodel gave the store a brighter interior and saw the West Coast Video department replaced with a large customer service counter and also created a special aisle for items in bulk sizes- no doubt a humble attempt to keep people in Acme and out of places like Costco and BJ’s.  The spread of the checkerboard arch remodel made little sense. The Middlesex store- Acme’s third most successful location in the area- received an even more elaborate version, while the Rockaway store that battled Morris Plains for first place on a weekly basis- was left with the 80’s remodel in place. Even more questionable was the spread of the checkerboard arch remodel to much smaller and less-successful stores in Succasunna, Union and Washington. Subsequent years saw most of the store’s increasingly-troublesome dairy and frozen food cases replaced, starting with the removal of the ancient coffin cases in the last two aisles.



As the turn of the century approached, Acme seemingly struggled with what to do to keep the Morris Plains location successful. Competition in the area was always fierce. The store was bookended by ShopRite stores in the center of Morristown and on the Morris Plains/Parsippany border, and while the former closed in the late 80’s, the antiquated Morris Plains store always maintained a healthy amount of business and had always floated the idea of relocating to a new location- something that was finally realized in fall of 2013, putting ShopRite even closer to the Acme’s doors. Stop & Shop’s nearby location in Cedar Knolls survived and even thrived when the chain pulled out of the area and the store was sold to Foodtown. The company would later return to the area in the late 90’s with an Edwards superstore constructed across the street from ShopRite and close enough to steal some of Acme’s business. A short while later, the Edwards was rebranded a Super Stop & Shop and brought things full circle for Ahold. A small Centennial A&P and Kings in Morristown rounded out the competition.

Acme briefly kicked around the idea of buying the land behind the store that was made available when Tetley closed its plant of many years. Like all rumors of Acme looking into building new stores in northern NJ, nothing came of them. Instead, it was decided the Morris Plains location would receive an extensive remodel, but not before the long-ignored Rockaway store got some attention in the form of the chalkboard market décor package that would attempt to keep it competitive in the face of new competition from ShopRite. Because of this, it was believed that the Morris Plains store would also receive the chalkboard market décor package; however, this was not the case.



Instead, the Morris Plains Acme would receive the Broadway décor package, more commonly referred to as the industrial circus on this site. It couldn’t have been more different from what greeted shoppers at the Rockaway location, with dark and mellow tones having been replaced by a festival of colors that wouldn’t look out of place at a carnival, creating one of the most divisive looks for a grocery store.  The remodel began with a budget of more than $4 million but was subsequently trimmed by 50%, mostly trimming an extensive exterior remodel that would have featured a tower entrance and stone sign structures by the parking lot entrances on Speedwell and Hanover Avenues. Still, the work was to be extensive as the majority of the interior was to be gutted and replaced, perhaps most impressively while the store remained open to shoppers. A grand aisle would feature a Starbucks department as well as produce, bakery, seafood and deli- the latter offering hot meal options. The opposite corner of the store called for a pharmacy and customer service department with one hour photo development. When the months of dust settled and the tarps came down, customers were treated to the equivalent of a brand new store. Only the previous, relatively-new frozen food and dairy cases remained, and even those were refreshed to match everything new that was installed. As Rockaway began suffering at the hands of ShopRite, Morris Plains experienced a slight uptick in business before settling back down to normal levels- perhaps not the desired outcome, but the results could have been worse.

The remodeling of the Rockaway and Morris Plains stores as well as the replacement of the Lincroft store in central NJ led many to believe that Acme was prepping for investment in the northern NJ area.  It was rumored that the company even hired a real estate specialist to investigate all available options but rumors of replacements or expansions of locations in Jersey City, Secaucus and East Rutherford (to name a few) never materialized as actual plans. Eventually new stores were constructed in Milltown and the Mount Freedom section of Randolph (a few miles down the road from Morris Plains) and an outdated location in Clifton was replaced with a new one on the other side of town but when further expansion into central NJ with stores in Marlboro and Freehold failed to produce positive results (two of the three stores closed not long after opening), all reasons for optimism were dashed. Acme continued closing the majority of its northern NJ locations and when the once-mighty Rockaway location faded into an oversized convenience store, it was obvious the company lacked any kind of solid plan. The Milltown and Clifton stores lost their pharmacies. Only the stores in Middlesex and Morris Plains remain as relics of brighter days. Are better times on the horizon?

I certainly hope they are, Rob! And Morris Plains might just give us an indication of that better times are finally here. As of November 10, this Acme has been faced with a giant new competitor exactly one mile away. The ShopRite of Greater Morristown, better known as Cedar Knolls, opened the doors to their 78,000 square foot, state of the art store. Should be enough to drive this Acme right out of business.Well, apparently not. I was here just a few weekends ago and found this store very busy. Nearly every register open and employees a plenty throughout the store. I could see no signs of this Acme taking a huge hit from the new ShopRite. Certainly business here has felt an impact but its location and ease of parking may be just what it needs to keep it going strong. The new pricing and more aggressive promotions certainly give it an edge not seen in the SuperValu days. We'll visit the new ShopRite in a Bonus Store post
up next.



Let's head in for a closer look...




The original entrance and exit were located where the windows are today. You can see scars from the railings and the magic carpets below...




A whole new entrance and vestibule now stand where the original customer service department was located.


The Industrial Circus, or Broadway decor as it was officially known as, looks really good here.


As Rob mentioned, there was a Starbuck at this store after the remodel. The coffee shop was located there in the front corner with a seating area under the hanging lights just inside the windows.




This store has been very nicely maintained since its last remodel.




A closer look at the former home of Starbucks, now stocked with seasonal items.


Seasonal extends over to the former seating area.






One very unusual thing here is the enormous size of the Seafood Department. The department is often paired with the "Meat"service counter. You can see an example of the pairing at the Mays Landing store by clicking here.


Can you spot something interesting here? The quality emblems hanging on either side of the department signage have "ACME" instead of the Albertsons logo. You can see an example of the more commonly seen emblems at the Milltown store by clicking here.






A very limited Wild Harvest department here. Just half of one side of the aisle.






















The Pharmacy took the place of the former Bakery.








All registers opened except for one!









Aerial Views...









Historic Aerials...


2007


2002


1995


1987


1979


1970
The 1970 aerial image reveals the original store our on Speedwell Avenue. The replacement store looks to have been 3 times the size!


1963


1957


A look at the nearby competition. The Morris Plains ShopRite to the North has closed, leaving just the Stop & Shop. A Wegmans is in the works just East on Route 10. Plans are on hold as ShopRite is suing  to stop the approval of the Wegmans site. ShopRite had previously been banned from building in the same spot due to environmental concerns leading them to build their replacement store on Hanover Avenue in Cedar Knolls. You can read more about it all in an article on nj.com by clicking here


Besides the new ShopRite, Acme faces compeition from a nearby Walmart and Foodtown. Although Foodtown's days may be numbered at this point. 


A classic Acme still going strong despite increased competition? Looks like it is. For now anyway. Thanks again to Rob for his contribution  to the 2013 Grand Finale!



1 comment:

  1. The Foodtown in Cedar Knolls has closed. With the (140,000-square-foot!!!) Wegman's under construction and new ShopRite nearby, Foodtown's demise was foreseeable. The owner also operated the long-closed Foodtown in Whippany (Pine Plaza).

    ReplyDelete